Ford Fusion Buying Guide: Cost, Reliability, and the Best Years to Buy

by Chris Teague

The bulbous curves of the 1996 Ford Taurus famously flopped, ceding the sedan sales number one spot to Toyota, so Ford countered in 2005 with a much more up-to-date proposition in the then-new Fusion. Chrysler and GM could only offer mediocre family sedans at the time, so it was up to Ford to take the fight to the Toyota Camry and Honda Accord.

During this period, Ford held a significant stake in Mazda, so it used the Japanese firm’s handling expertise to create a car that was as capable and entertaining to drive as it was good-looking. Indeed, it came out ahead of the Honda Accord and Toyota Camry in many comparison tests as well as impressing in customer test drives.

Though the Fusion name had been first used on a compact European-market crossover, this US-market car was based on the Mazda6, as were its more upscale relatives, the Mercury Milan and Lincoln Zephyr/MKZ. Those cars and the Fusion, unlike the Mazda, were also earlyish adopters of hybrid technology, with electrically assisted models launching in 2010.

And even though it never clawed back that top sales spot from either the Accord or Camry, the first Fusion was popular with its owners. Ford aimed to build on this with the 2013 second-gen model. Like the largely unloved 1990s Ford Contour, this new Fusion was developed entirely in-house in concert with Ford of Europe, who sold a slightly smaller version as the Mondeo.

Fusion number two looked faintly like a four-door Aston Martin but had room comparable to a Camry. It drove just as well as the original but was better made, meaning fewer reliability foibles over time. It also gained available all-wheel drive and a plug-in (PHEV) Ford Fusion hybrid (PHEV) version, some ten years ahead of PHEVs coming into vogue. This new Fusion debuted to serious popularity, with more than 600,000 cars sold in the first two years. But with sedan sales steadily falling in favor of crossovers after that, Ford did not see fit to give us a third generation. At least not yet.

The automaker gave the Fusion significant updates in 2017 and 2019, in the latter case fitting the car with a wide variety of active safety features, including lane-keeping assist and automatic emergency braking. With Ford’s eye on SUVs, the Fusion was discontinued in 2020, but leftover models could still be found on dealer lots even into 2021. Today, Ford’s only car product is the Mustang but used Fusions abound as good deals.

Ford Fusion: Cost, Reliability, and the Best Years to Buy

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Ford Fusion years are the best?

Undoubtedly the newest ones, 2019 and 2020. These are the best-equipped versions, they tend to have the least wear and tear on them, and they have good reliability records according to data from places like Consumer Reports, J.D. Power, and RepairPal. But all of the second-generation models (2013-2020) are fairly reliable machines save for the eary Fusion Energi and hybrid models. We’d stick to 2016 or newer if you’re interested in one of those, as there were some mechanical updates that improved transmission reliability on them.

What are the worst Ford Fusion years?

First-generation Fusions tend to be less reliable than their second-generation replacements, and according to places like RepairPal and CarComplaints, the worst years for Fusion complaints are 2010 to 2012. Most issues center around electrical, steering, and especially brake system issues, but these cars also have a predisposition to rust in very snowy climes. Early Ford Hybrid batteries and systems also aren’t as robust as their Toyota counterparts, and that’s reflected in the relative rarity and resale values of the first-gen Fusion hybrid.

Is a used Ford Fusion a good deal?

Yes. While the first-gen models aren’t as desirable, the second-gen Fusion is a good car at a good price. The latest 2019 and 2020 models can top $22,000 in good shape or with extended warranties, but even among them, it’s possible to find clean, lightly used, sub-50,000-mile examples for less than $16,000, and even less for pre-2017s. Bargain hunting requires time, but the Fusion offers a Camry-like experience for less money. The best deals are found on the pure gas models, which are also the most trouble-free Fusions.

Ford Fusion Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Sharp styling, lots of room
  • Good driving dynamics in both generations
  • Availalbe hybrid and AWD variants

Cons:

  • Not as deluxe as its price tag suggests
  • First generation model has a below-average repair record
  • Non-hybrids lag rivals in MPG

Ford Fusion Generations


Second Generation (2013-2020)

Ford overhauled the Fusion for the 2013 model year, dovetailing its development with the European Ford Mondeo. The new car brought strikingly sharp styling and loads of new tech, including available all-wheel drive (AWD) and the Fusion Energi plug-in hybrid (PHEV) model. A very potent 325-horsepower EcoBoost V6 was added during the car’s 2017 refresh. With that engine, the Fusion Sport was the most powerful mainstream midsize sedan of its era, but most Fusion buyers chose fours, and many were available.

All through the run the lowest-end engine was the 175-horsepower 2.5-liter Duratec, but there was also a turbocharged 1.5-liter EcoBoost from 2014-2020 (181 hp) and a 1.6-liter EcoBoost four (179 hp) in 2013-2014. Consumers could also choose a 240-hp 2.0-liter EcoBoost Turbo. Hybrid models use a 2.0-liter Duratec four mated with an electric motor for up to 188 hp. Most second-gen Fusions use a six-speed automatic transmission, but a few 1.5s have a six-speed manual, and hybrid models have a continuously variable automatic transmission (CVT).

About 60% of used gas-only Fusions are 1.5s, which is a perfectly acceptable engine and also happens to return the best economy among the gas models, up to 27 mpg combined. AWD comes only on the top two engines, but the Fusion is a sure-footed, capable-handling machine even in foul weather and in front-drive form. The 2.7-liter Fusion Sport feels truly quick and commands a small price premium, but the other gas engines do not. Hybrid Fusions are also capable drivers, but they feel a little slow.

Over time, the second-generation Fusion also got several advanced driver aids. Ford added lane-keeping assist, blind-spot monitoring with rear cross-traffic alerts, inflatable seatbelts, automatic stop-start, forward-collision warnings, adaptive cruise control, automatic emergency braking, and more. The best-equipped versions are 2019 and 2020 models, which have some of these features standard. There’s plenty of room, too. The second-gen Fusion’s back seat has 38.3 inches of legroom and there’s a 16 cubic-foot trunk, more than adequate numbers.

Higher trim levels like the Fusion Platinum and Titanium got luxury-level MSRPs, but Ford was generous with features and tech. Top models like the Ford Fusion Titanium got upgraded infotainment systems, leather seating, rain-sensing wipers, dual-zone climate controls, automatic high beams, a Wi-Fi hotspot, a power moonroof, and more. Ford’s SYNC 3 infotainment system was added in 2017, bringing Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and other features.

Despite all these qualities and a decent reliability record, second-generation Fusions won’t break the bank. The newest models, with low mileages under 50,000, are still $20,000+ vehicles, especially the final Fusion Sports. But it’s possible to find a wide array of clean, low-mileage 2015 to 2018 Fusions for less than $16,000. We’d steer clear of the early hybrid models unless the deal is very tempting, as the gas models have better repair records, but all of these Fusions are a potentially good deal.

2009 Ford Fusion Preview summaryImage

First Generation (2006-2012)

The Fusion entered Ford's automotive lineup with the 2006 model year. Built at Ford's plant in Hermosillo, Sonora, Mexico, the Fusion rides on a platform created by Mazda for the Mazda6 and shared with the Mercury Milan and the Lincoln MKZ. Slotted between the Focus and the Five Hundred (which replaced the Taurus for a short time), the Fusion was the first Ford vehicle to showcase the automaker's distinctive new design style, which continues to this day. The exterior design was inspired by the Ford 427 concept car and highlighted by the three-bar chrome grille and multi-element projector-beam headlights up front.

Upon introduction, the Fusion came in S, SE, and SEL trims, all powered by a base 160-horsepower, 2.3-liter, all-aluminum DOHC Duratec four-cylinder engine mated to either a five-speed manual or a five-speed automatic transmission. Owners could opt for a 221-hp, 3.0-liter Duratec V6 for the Ford Fusion SE and Fusion SEL. Variable cam timing and electronic throttle control on both engines maximized fuel economy and responsiveness while ensuring low emissions.

The Fusion displayed an exterior design described as athletic by the automaker, with a muscular stance and plenty of room in the cabin for both front- and rear-seat passengers. Emphasis was placed on fuel economy, safety features, and good driving dynamics, as well as on design and interior space.

A stiff chassis ensured responsive handling and minimal flexing, while a four-wheel independent suspension provided a comfortable ride. The Fusion sat on a 107-inch wheelbase with an overall length of 190.2 inches and a width of 72.2 inches. Those generous measurements for a midsize car, aided by the fact that Ford pushed the C-pillar back as far as possible, ensured ample legroom in the rear seat and plenty of space throughout the cabin. Fortunately, cargo space didn't suffer, with the Fusion offering a respectable 15.8 cubic feet of space in the trunk.

Inside, standard features for the five-passenger Fusion included front bucket seats, remote keyless entry, a tilting and telescopic steering wheel, cruise control, and a 60/40-split, fold-flat rear seat.

A year after launch, in 2007, Ford added an optional AWD system for V6-powered trims and offered Sirius satellite radio as an option in SE and SEL trims.

In addition, front-seat side and side-curtain airbags became standard on all Ford Fusion trims. Other new standard features included an MP3 input jack, while a DVD-based navigation system was added as an option.

For 2008, antilock brakes and a tire-pressure monitoring system joined the standard equipment list. Late in the 2008 model year, Ford added its SYNC communications and connectivity technology as an option, enabling hands-free access to cell phones and MP3 players through the car's audio system. Other new features for 2008 included an optional color-configurable ambient interior lighting system and an optional Sport Appearance Package, which included a black chrome grille, a unique spoiler, color-keyed fog lights, a sport-tuned suspension, red seat inserts, and red stitching on the seats, steering wheel, and console.

Stability control, which improved handling and wheel traction, became an option in 2009. In addition, Ford offered a Blue Suede options package for SE and SEL trims, which included a charcoal black interior, ambient lighting, 18-inch painted wheels, and Alcantara blue-suede seat and door-panel trim inserts.

Related Topics

Chris is an automotive journalist covering new vehicle reveals, news, and technology. He loves digging into the details to tell entertaining and informative stories.

Now a regular contributor to CarGurus, Matt Rigby's career has covered everything from road testing and reporting for weekly magazines such as Auto Express and Autocar, to writing for hugely enthusiastic online communities such as PistonHeads.

The content above is for informational purposes only and should be independently verified. Please see our Terms of Use for more details.